Join free

All stories

Walnut Creek · Police · Housing · Transit · Feature · Fri Oct 2

Only on CBS News · open the full fact check

Walnut Creek girl's 1976 disappearance remains unsolved after 50 years

What the reporting says

CBS News reports that Lisa Dickinson, a nine-year-old Walnut Creek girl, disappeared 50 years ago, and that investigators are certain someone with information could still come forward. Her parents reported her missing the evening of September 5, 1976. Her bicycle was found hidden under a tree at Heather Farm Park.

  • CBS News reports that Lisa Dickinson disappeared from Walnut Creek 50 years ago, when she was nine years old, and that her case remains unsolved. Investigators told the station they are certain someone with information could still come forward. The report revisits the 1976 case through the memories of an officer who took the first call.
  • Lew Doty was a new beat cop with Walnut Creek Police on September 5, 1976. He took the evening call from dispatchers when Lisa's parents reported her missing, and he went to their home. Her parents told him she had left on her bicycle to look for a shortcut to a nearby BART station for a trip planned for the next day.
  • Doty knew that canals ran along Heather Farm Park, where Lisa had been headed, and he told CBS News his first thought was that there might be a drowning victim. It was dark when he and other officers searched the park. His light caught a reflection under an oak tree, where he found Lisa's bicycle hidden.

Read it at CBS News

The full fact check1 outlet

Checked Sat Oct 3, 1:36 AM · 2 of 2 pages read

coverage1 outlet

1 newsroom

CBS News

News report · Juliette Goodrich · Fri Oct 2, 8:40 PM

“50 years later, Lisa Dickinson's disappearance from Walnut Creek remains unsolved”

Fifty years ago, a Walnut Creek girl disappeared when she was just nine years old, but investigators are certain someone with information could still come forward. On September 5, 1976, Lew Doty was a new beat cop with Walnut Creek Police. He took the call from dispatchers that evening when Lisa Dickinson's parents reported her missing.

The opening, as CBS News wrote it

0 documents linked16 quotes13 of 17 paragraphs say where facts came from

Read the full story at CBS News

CBS News

News report · Fri Oct 2, 8:30 PM

“Walnut Creek girl's disappearance remains unsolved 5 decades later”

0 documents linked0 quotes

The page has no story text the Wire can read

Read the full story at CBS News

Comments

Comments go up at once and are checked automatically: no links but public records, no phone numbers, emails or street addresses, nothing hateful or threatening. Three reports from readers take a comment down. Leave the name empty to post as Reader and a short code.

    No comments yet.

    Keep reading

    1. “Luxury living, courtesy of Walnut Creek-based Davidon Homes”Walnut Creek · Fri Oct 2
    2. Walnut Creek lists below market rate homes for first-time buyers, workshop set October 21Walnut Creek · Fri Oct 2
    3. California average for regular gas rises to $6.40, near the state record, AAA saysWalnut Creek · Fri Oct 2
    4. Juries in Martinez convict former airline pilot and Walnut Creek woman of child sex abuseMartinez · Thu Oct 1
    5. Clayton Bikes closes its storefront and moves its staff to Encina Bikes in Walnut CreekWalnut Creek · Wed Sep 30
    6. SUV hits PG&E pole in Walnut Creek, closing a lane near Ygnacio PlazaWalnut Creek · Wed Sep 30
    7. Three people shot on Pittsburg BART transfer platform; one suspect in custodyWalnut Creek · Tue Sep 29
    8. County to close Schroder pedestrian bridge over Treat Boulevard for rehabilitation workWalnut Creek · Tue Sep 29

    How the checks work

    The short version

    The Wire shows what it could check, never a score: who covered the story, whether its facts match the public record where a fact could be checked, and how much of it is an agency's own release. It describes the reporting, never the people in it.

    How it is checked5 rules
    • Coverage counts every outlet that told the story, once each, by kind: official, newsroom, blog. Outlets with one owner count once.
    • Where the Wire's own records hold the fact (a vote, a meeting, an amount, a call, a listing), the story and the record are set side by side.
    • An agency's own release is the record itself; an outlet that prints it as its story counts once. How much of a newsroom's story is an agency's release is measured word for word, in runs of five words, and shown from 40%.
    • Each story's key facts are checked for independent confirmation: first by rules against the Wire's records and the agencies' own releases, then each morning by research. A confirmation counts only when the Wire read the source's page itself and found the sentence on it; a government page, a public record or another newsroom's own reporting, never a copy of the story or a social post. A source that tells a fact differently is shown beside the story.
    • A page the Wire cannot read is never guessed at: it shows only its own headline, quoted.
    Sources2 records
    1. News reportFri Oct 2CBS NewsRead
    2. News reportFri Oct 2CBS NewsRead